Monday, 30 April 2012

The second shia tradition

The second Shi'a tradition




Ansar.org states:
Muhammad ibn Abi 'Umayr-Hisham ibn Salim, who narrates that
-Imam Ja'far as-Sadiq said: "When ['Umar] proposed to Amir al-Mu'minin, he said, 'She is a child.'
Then he ['Umar] met 'Abbas and asked him, 'What is wrong with me? Is there a problem with me?' 'Abbas asked, 'Why?' 'Umar replied, 'I asked your nephew for his daughter's hand in marriage, and he rejected me. Oh, I swear by Allah, I will fill the well of Zamzam with earth, I will destroy every honour that you have, and I will set up two witnesses to testify that he stole, that I may cut off his right hand.'
'Abbas thereupon came to 'Ali and informed him of what had transpired. He asked 'Ali to put the matter in his hands, and 'Ali complied." (Furu' al-Kafi, vol. 5 p. 347-348, Dar al-Adwa, Beirut 1992)



Reply one - other than condemning Umar, the tradition sheds no light on Umar marrying Umme Kalthum (as)



Afriki needs stronger spectacles for the tradition of al Kafi that he no doubt is advancing to prove Umar's esteemed status in marrying Umme Kalthum (as), does nothing for him, other than present him as liar who was willing to bring false allegations against an innocent man to gain some type of personal benefit. An individual who threatens to amputate the hand of a man who has committed no crime can never be deemed as just. Rather he is an oppressor. Had Afriki had an ounce of intelligence he would have never bothered to produce a reference that presents Umar in such a degrading manner.

If we scrutinise the tradition we see that key words that would have otherwise proven Afriki's case are missing. We do not see the words "UMME KALTHUM" "Nikah" and nor is there any clarification that Abbas was witness to this wedding. This reference only highlights Umar's actions, that he was prepared to bring a false allegation against Imam 'Ali (as) to get his own way. The tradition does not establish the marriage of Umar. In fact the tradition is so vague it does not even mention UMME KALTHUM by name, so on what basis has Afriki reached his conclusion?


Reply Two - You can only rely on evidence that supports your claim



The Ahl'ul Sunnah claim that Imam 'Ali (as) happily married his daughter to Umar. This tradition does not concur with such a claim, there is no evidence that Imam 'Ali (as) willingly married his daughter to Umar, this cannot not be surmised from the text, nor from interpreting its meaning. Ahl'ul Sunnah's argument cannot be proven from the text, nor logic since the tradition that Afriki relied on makes no reference to UMME KALTHUM binte Ali.


Reply Three - You can only cite evidence that you believe to be true



It is indeed incredible that Afriki has cited a reference that he does not accept. There is no way that he would accept that Imam 'Ali (as) rejected Umar's offer and then Umar threatened to bring false witnesses and have the hand of Imam 'Ali (as) amputated! If Afriki is citing evidence that he himself does not believe then why is he producing it as evidence to support his case?


Reply Four - Personal viewpoints do not constitute proof



Afriki (in light of this hadith) has deduced that this proves that Imam 'Ali (as) married his daughter Umme Kalthum (as) to Umar. We should point out that in the same way that Afriki's very own Nasibi Imam Ibn Taymeeya stated that the 'personal views' of Ayesha and Umar cannot constitute proof, - the personal views of Afriki or for that matter any Shi'a scholar cannot constitute proof, unless such comments are accompanied by clear unequivocal evidence. If the proof has been based on the 'personal opinions' - of a very vague tradition, then personal opinions have no weighting to the argument.


Reply Five - Examination of the Arabic destroys Afriki's claim that this hadith referred to 11-year-old Umme Kalthum binte Fatima (as)



If we examine the Arabic closely we will see that in reply to Umar's offer, Imam 'Ali (as) replied "ka la na Sabeeya". Afriki had defined this as 'She is a child.' In Arabic Sabtha is not just a child - it's a milk fed child (i.e. Is still breast fed). We should point out that Imam used exactly the same term in the tradition of Tabaqat Ibn Sa'd.

The term Sabeeya here would in effect deem marriage impossible since this refers to a milk fed child, how could Imam 'Ali (as) marry his daughter when she was STILL being suckled? Is this believable in terms of logic? The word definitely refers to an infant child that of course infers one being weened on milk, and has been used by Allah (swt) in Surah Maryam verse 29 when referring to Hadhrath Esau (as):

But she pointed to the babe. They said: "How can we talk to one who is a (Sabeeya) child in the cradle?"

Yusuf Ali translates the word as 'child in the cradle' and other English transliterations such as Pickthall and T.B. Irving have also translated Sabeeya in the same way.

The term Sabeeya here would in effect deem marriage impossible since this refers to a milk fed child, how could Imam 'Ali (as) marry his daughter when she was STILL being suckled? Is this believable in terms of logic? The word definitely refers to milk, and has been used by Allah (swt) in Surah Maryam�

A child that is so young that she is being given milk is referred to as "Sabeeya". Now as Afriki had himself pointed out:


Ansar.org states:
Umme Kalthum was the second daughter of 'Ali and Fatima, and the youngest of their four children. She was born in about the year 6 AH. She became of marriageable age during the khilafat of 'Umar ibn al-Khattab, and the khalifa asked for her hand in marriage.


Now the marriage of Umar to Umme Kalthum binte 'Ali (as) is alleged to have taken place in 17 Hijri, this would have made her eleven years of age. This being the case how can Imam 'Ali (as) refer to his daughter (in this tradition) as being milk fed? Umar died in 23 Hijri and the maximum age that a child is milk fed is four or five, this being the case then how could this same milk fed child, married aged five - attain puberty and give birth to two children in six years? It is agreed by both Sunni and Shi'a Ulema that where a tradition contravenes logic, the fault lies with the narrator's recollection of the event, not the Imam (as) and such an illogical narration cannot constitute proof.

Some might assert that Imam 'Ali (as) use of the word "Sabeeya" was just an example that she was young. To counter such an assertion we should point out that the term Sabeer is an exclusive one that refers specifically to a child that is so young that they are still being milk fed. If Umme Kalthum was slightly older but still young Imam 'Ali (as) would have used the words "Sagheer" - that means Young. This was a term that was used by Rasulullah (s), we read in Sunan Nasai that when Abu Bakr and Umar asked for the hand of Sayyida Fatima (as) Rasulullah (s) made replied "Na Sagheera" - meaning "No she is too young" rather than "Na Sabeeya" meaning she is milk fed. Applying this to the hadith that Afriki had advanced, the term Sagheera would have applied to eleven year old Umme Kalthum. The term Sabeeya that Imam 'Ali (as) used was much more applicable to Umme Kalthum daughter of Abu Bakr, as according to Ahl'ul Sunnah she was just five years of age at the time (17 Hijri) and a 5 year old child can still be milk fed (Sabeeya). In light of Ayesha's stipulations for marriage, when Umar asked to marry Umme Kalthum binte Abu Bakr. When a correct interpretation of a tradition can be made (in light of proven facts) then that tradition can be accepted. From the authentic Ahl'ul Sunnah sources it is quite clear that Umme Kalthum binte Abu Bakr was this milk fed child, and if the hadith is interpreted in this way then we have no bone of contention with the Nasibi.

If the Nasibi are going to ask why this tradition exists, a tradition that makes no sense, then exactly the same could be asked of the tradition in Tabaqat ibn Sa'd where Imam 'Ali (as) refers to his daughter as a milk fed child.


Reply Six - Imam 'Ali (as) rejected Umar's offer



If the Nasibi are going to take issue against us with regards to these words in the traditions, namely Umar's comments to Abbas:

'I asked your nephew for his daughter's hand in marriage, and he rejected me'.

We should point that the term 'rejection' can also be found in Ahl'ul Sunnah texts. The Sahaba had pointed out to Umar that he had been rejected by Imam 'Ali (as) and you can see this in 'Asba fi tamheedh al Sahaba' Volume 14 page 468 - where the Sahaba said to Umar - 'Ali rejected you'. When this term appeared on the lips of the Sahaba (in Sunni texts) then our opponents have no right to raise objections against us. The word Nikah cannot be found in the whole narration, the only thing that is proven from the text is that Imam 'Ali (as) rejected Umar's proposal to marry his daughter.


Reply Seven - The tradition portrays Umar as an unjust liar



In the third portion of this reference Umar says:

"Oh, I swear by Allah, I will fill the well of Zamzam with earth, I will destroy every honour that you have, and I will set up two witnesses to testify that he stole, that I may cut off his right hand.'

There is no doubt that this potion shall cause immense pain to Afriki and his likes since it portrays the second khalifa as unjust. We would like to point out to Afriki that if he has presented this reference to 'prove' that this marriage took place, then he cannot just accept the portion that supposedly supports his claim. You have to accept the tradition in its entirety. If a defence lawyer in a court case is relying on a witness testimony of an event as proof, he will have to rely on his ENTIRE testimony - he can't take bits that he likes and discredit the bits that he does not. So tell us Afriki since you have presented this evidence as 'proof' to support you claim, does this mean that you (as the hadith states) accept that Umar was an unjust liar? If you do not then why are you citing this reference as evidence to prove your argument?

If anything, our assertion is that this evidence tallies up with the text of Ahl'ul Sunnah Tadhkira Khawwas page 181 Chapter 11 in which Sibt ibn Jauzi al Hanafi states that Abbas had asked that Imam 'Ali (as) marry his daughter as he "received unacceptable words from Umar". This was the unacceptable language that had been cited in al Kafi. These two traditions clearly tally up with one another, and in the same way that a mother seeks to cover up the faults of her daughter, Ibn Jauzi had sought to cast a veil over the words of the second khalifa towards Hadhrath Abbas.


Reply Eight - Afriki's claim cannot be proven from the text



In the fourth and final portion of this hadith, we read as follows:

'Abbas thereupon came to 'Ali and informed him of what had transpired. He asked 'Ali to put the matter in his hands, and 'Ali complied."

We would urge our readers to carefully read through this hadith from start through to its conclusion, does it inform us that Imam 'Ali (as) married his daughter Umme Kalthum to Umar? Proof of any argument can be determined from the words that are used, if the words are clear and a narration is complete. Now does this tradition cited by Afriki have a clear ending from where we can conclude what happened? Once Imam 'Ali (as) hands his daughter over to Abbas (ra) what happens next? The hadith does not state that Abbas then married the girl to Umar. There is no reference to any "Nikah" taking place between Umar and Umme Kalthum (as). Neither do we learn of a public Nikah with multiple attendees, nor a small private Nikah with Abbas present as Umme Kalthum's witness. If you are trying to convince your opponents of an argument - guesswork / assumptions can never be advanced as proof. So, based purely on the text of al Kafi, without an interpolation exactly what has Afriki proven from this tradition? Nothing from this al Kafi tradition points to a marriage taking place, so would like to ask this Nasibi 'how have you arrived at this conclusion?'


Reply nine - Historical precedent refutes Afriki's false claim



Imam of Ahl'ul Sunnah Allamah Shibli Numani in his authority work 'al Faruq" whilst discussing how best to eliminate doubts over the authenticity of any given event, states:

"It should at first be ascertained whether the event itself lies within the pale of possibility, for, if the event is not possible, the veracity of the narrator is useless. Ibn Khaldun has also pointed out that possibility in such instances does not signify logical possibility but that which is in accordance with the laws of Nature and Society"
al Faruq Volume 1 page 18

With this point in mind we should point out that in Sunan Nasai Volume 6 page 62 "Kitab Nikah" and Riyadh al Nadira Volume 2 page 128 we learn that that:

"Abu Bakr and Umar both made a proposal to marry Fatima, the daughter of Rasulullah (s), but he (s) stated that she was too young".
Riyadh al Nadira Volume 2 page 128

When Rasulullah (s) was not prepared to marry his own daughter to Umar on account that he was not her 'kuff' on account of her young age, this clearly referred to age gap between her and Umar, as she was not too young to marry Hadhrath 'Ali (as). With this in mind we should point out that UMME KALTHUM was the youngest child of Sayyida Fatima (as). This would have therefore meant a massive age gap between Umar and UMME KALTHUM. We also assert that Imam 'Ali (as) would have likewise rejected Umar due to the age gap, to do otherwise and accept the proposal would have contradicted the Sunnah of Rasulullah (s). Alhamdolillah, we the Shi'a do NOT believe that Imam 'Ali (as) would ever contravene a Sunnah / precedent that had been set by Rasulullah (s).


Reply ten - Ahl'ul Sunnah aqeedah requires two witnesses to a wedding



As proof we shall rely in the following authority texts of Ahl'ul Sunnah:


  1. Al Hidayaa ma al dhur'ayaath, page 304 Kitab Nikah
  2. Al Durrul Mukthar, Volume 2 page 2 Kitab Nikah
  3. Fatawa Qadhi Khan, Volume 1 page 153 Kitab Nikah
  4. Al Fiqh a'la madhaib al Raya Volume 4 page 28 Kitab Nikah
  5. Taufa Ithna Ashari page 258

We read in Taufa Ithna Ashari page 258:

"The difference between the rules of Talaq and Nikah are that with a Nikah the necessary components are the declaration and two witnesses"

We read in Al Hidayaa ma al dhur'ayaath, page 304 Kitab Nikah:

"Without the presence of two witnesses a Muslim Nikah is not correct"


The Shi'a Madhab deems the presence of a witness and declaration to be a Sunnah



We are relying on the following Shi'a texts to support our assertion:


  1. Sharh al Islam, Chapter Sharh Islam, Bab al Ahdah
  2. Jawhur Al Ahkam Volume 2 page 29 "Kitab Nikah" (Tehran edition)

"The presence of two witnesses at a Nikah ceremony is mustahab (recommended), and their absence is makruh (not favourable). Imam 'Ali (as) stated that a Nikah should not be conducted when a guardian and witnesses are absent. Amongst the Shi'a, Abi Aqeel school and a group amongst Ahl'ul Sunnah have issued fatwas that the presence of witnesses to the Nikah is wajib"

In Sunni and Shi'a Fiqh the declaration and the presence of a witnesses is compulsory. Our challenge to the adherents of Ahl'ul Sunnah who claim Umar married UMME KALTHUM binte Fatima (as) is simple:

Produce us evidence that will shed light to the following:


  1. When was the declaration for the suspicious Nikah made?
  2. Who were the witnesses to the Nikah?

The Ahl'ul Sunnah will never be able to reply to these two questions, since the identity of the witnesses and the declaration can be located in any of their authoritative books, and it is on this basis that we assert that this entire event is a concoction.


Reply eleven - The al Kafi tradition does not support Afriki's claim



The al Kafi tradition that Afriki brought before the Shi'a to embarrass serves only as a slap in his face. UMME KALTHUM here refers to UMME KALTHUM binte Junth, and we would urge our opponents to examine our replies with an open mind. As we have stated Sabeeya refers to a milk fed child, a term that exists in al Kafi and Tabaqat Ibn Sa'd.

From examining the narration from start to end there is no reference to Imam 'Ali (as) referring to Umar as his son in law, nor is there any reference to a wedding ceremony. All that this reference proves is that Umar was an oppressor, an unjust liar who brought suffering to the Ahl'ul bayt (as). If Afriki by citing this 'proof' expects the Shi'a community to sit up and afford respect to Umar based on this tradition then we are afraid that his efforts have failed abysmally. We shall never deem an unjust person as an Imam, as to do so would contradict the Qur'an, wherein Hadhrath Ibrahim (as) had stipulated that Imamate not be given to the unjust.

The first shia tradition

The first Shi'a tradition




Ansar.org states:
'Ali ibn Ibrahim-from his father-from Ibn Abi 'Umayr-from Hisham ibn Salim and Hammad-from Zurarah, who narrates that
-Imam Ja'far as-Sadiq said regarding the marriage of Umme Kalthum: "That was a 'woman' who was taken from us by force." (Furu' al-Kafi, vol. 5 p. 347, Dar al-Adwa, Beirut 1992)
[The word 'woman' here is an attempt from the writer of this article to preserve the honour of the Ahl al-Bayt, since a literal translation of the original Arabic would prove too vulgar.]



Reply one - You can only cite a reference when it supports your claim



A truism of rational thought is that you can only advance a proof if it supports your argument. In this case the evidence that Afriki has cited does not prove his claim. Afriki is alleging that this tradition proves that Umme Kalthum (as), daughter of Imam 'Ali (as), married 'Umar. But this Nasibi has not bothered to actually look at the tradition he cited and what it actually does prove? If we look at the tradition, we do not see the name "'Umar" or the word "marriage". He has cunningly juxtaposed his own interpretation of this Hadith into this paragraph and misleadingly given the impression that the Umm Kalthum being spoken of is the one who is the daughter of Ali (as) and is the figure central to this alleged marriage. There is no mention of "'Ali" or "binte Fatima" - just "Umme Kalthum". When 'Umar's name is not established from this narration, where is Afriki's proof? There is not even the slightest indication that 'Umar is being referred to here.

Afriki is clutching at straws; he is relying on a vague tradition from al Kafi that does not support his stance, not even in the slightest, so how has he concluded that this tradition proves the marriage of Umme Kalthum (as) to Umar? All this proves is the wonderful imagination that these Nasibis have� an imagination that aims to deceive their followers and those that would listen to them. As noted, Umm Kalthum was a popular name amongst Arabs...it still is to this day, and numerous ladies from the descendants of Ahl-ulBait have been named Umm Kalthum. Is this, or is this not, the Umm Kalthum that was allegedly married to 'Umar. Where is 'Umar mentioned? Where are these words being used to mention marriage�there is no mention of marriage save in the delusional mind of Afriki who SEES WHAT HE WANTS TO SEE. Indeed, NOTHING of any substance to this argument can be substantiated from this Hadith. This is an example of Nasibi logic - it is also called clutching for straws.

He cites a Hadith which is totally vague as to who it refers to and to which event it refers to. It cannot be used as evidence - we don't know who the Hadith is speaking of - WHICH Umm Kalthum is it speaking of, there were so many. And is it even speaking of marriage? Instead, it sounds like it is speaking of a lady by this name who was kidnapped�but I don't know. We just can't say as the whole tradition is so ambiguous.


Reply two - A claim can only be proven when the text supports it



We would suggest that Afriki look at the 'proof' that he has advanced. We shall analyse this tradition by the laws of logic and intellect - these dictate that proofs can only be established when there is supporting evidence for them. Using logic and not blind bigotry that is clutching at straws, Afriki's claim cannot be upheld.

Consider this. Afriki is seeking to convince us that the marriage of Umme Kalthum to Umar is established by this reference. The text refers to the marriage of Umme Kalthum (as) - marriage to whom? The crucial words Umme Kalthum binte Fatima are NOT present here, and the name Umme Kalthum was in common usage at that time, much more so in the house of 'Umar - who had four wives by that name. The text makes no reference as to WHO the parents of Umme Kalthum were in this tradition. The text is devoid of crucial information that would be necessary to sustain Afriki's argument. It fails to inform us:


  1. Who Umme Kalthum married.
  2. The names of Umme Kalthum's parents
  3. The name of Umme Kalthum's husband

The absence of this key information makes Afriki's claim null and void. The text he relied on here does not prove that Umme Kalthum (as) binte Fatima (as) married 'Umar.


Reply Three - A proof can only be accepted when the subject matter is proven



It is common sense that you can only rely on evidence as proof when the subject matter can be proven from the text. Unfortunately this cannot be proven here, since the names of key players are missing, most crucially Umme Kalthum "binte Fatima" and "'Umar". How can Afriki claim that this tradition proves the marriage of Umme Kalthum to 'Umar when there is no mention of 'Umar in the text? How ridiculous!


Reply four - even the words in the tradition fail to support Afriki's claim



Is it possible that, assuming this tradition mentioned the words Umme Kalthum "binte Fatima" or "binte 'Ali", then would this have served as evidence for Afriki's claim? The text does not make any reference to Umme Kalthum's parents. Our opponents can go back to the oldest copy of Al Kafi, and will see that only Umme Kalthum is mentioned there and there is no mention of her parents. If we look at the Arabic in the text, we see that Imam Ja'far al Sadiq (as) only said five words:


  1. Faqatha
  2. Ina
  3. Zaalikun
  4. Furuj
  5. Ghuzubna

On the basis of five words said about an individual who is not properly named, and none of which deal with marriage, Afriki jumps to his erroneous conclusion! Now, we would urge Afriki to look at the 'proof' that he had cited. Had this Nasibi had even an ounce of dignity, he would be deeply embarrassed at producing 5 ambiguous words as evidence before the Shi'a for his claims. This evidence cannot prove his claim, not even in the slightest, not even in the most corrupt court of law in the whole wide world.


Reply five - Personal viewpoints cannot constitute proof



Imam of the Nasibis, their Grand Wizard, Ibn Taymeeya, in Minhaaj as Sunnah, Volume 5, page 136 (Egypt edition) stated, as follows:

"The personal views of Ayesha and 'Umar cannot constitute proof".

We should point out that the Al Kafi tradition fails to shed light on the age of Umme Kalthum. We proved earlier on that the Umme Kalthum who was married to 'Umar was the daughter of Abu Bakr, NOT the daughter of Fatima (as). When Ahl'ul Sunnah Ulema of the rank of the grand wizard, Ibn Taymeeya, are not prepared to rely on the personal views of their esteemed personalities such as Ayesha and 'Umar, then we likewise reject the viewpoints of a Nasibi in the absence of proof. This is particularly so when our assertion with regards to the identity of Umme Kalthum (as) can be established by evidence. In short, the viewpoint of Afriki does not constitute proof. As he insists on adhering to them, we are led to conclude that his is only a personal viewpoint, that is, one which has no proof and is a baseless allegation. He has every right to have his viewpoint. Just as he has the right to believe, as do many Nasibis, that Ayatullah Khomeini was a really a CIA agent, or even believe that Tabari was a Shi'a, that Maudoodi was a Shi'a, or even that the Pope is Jewish, or maybe even that that the Sun orbits the Earth and that they are the real believers and what is written on this website is a black magic spell so powerful that it is bewitching you into seeing writing that does not actually exist. Others call this type of 'personal viewpoint' blind bigotry�embarrassingly blind, even for more moderate Sunnis. I call it the death-rows of a set of beliefs that are intellectually on the retreat.


Reply six - this hadith can be rejected due to Shi'a rules on conflicting hadith



Unfortunately Afriki has failed to conduct research into Shi'a hadith methodology. One principle is that where two hadith conflict with one another, then both are to be discarded. In this context, there is a hadith called Meerath al Uqul in which Imam Ja'far Sadiq (as) replied to a query that Imam 'Ali (as) married his daughter Umme Kalthum (as) to 'Umar. The Imam (as) replied, declaring, "Whoever claims such a thing is lying". In theory we now might have had two conflicting hadith, and under Shi'a jurisprudence both would be rejected. However, the Hadith of Meerath al Uqul is strong and categorically mentions WHICH Umm Kalthum is being discussed, and in WHICH context. Therefore the Shi'a view is that there was no such marriage. The al Kafi tradition does not prove this conclusively, since the parentage of UMME KALTHUM is not clarified in the tradition, and we know that Umar had several wives called UMME KALTHUM.


Reply seven - when the identity of a person is unknown then such a tradition can be rejected



Imam of Ahl'ul Sunnah Shah Abdul Aziz, in Taufa Ithna Ashari, Part 8, Chapter "Muthaeen Sahaba", responding to the Shi'a claim that when Umar went to attack the home of Sayyida Fatima (as) he was accompanied by an individual called "Kunfuz" - argues that this narration can be rejected since Kunfuz is an unknown personality. He conveniently forgets to mention the fact that while Kunfuz's existence may be doubted by that tradition, the whole Hadith makes the context in which the event occurred to be clear and precise, thus making the rest of the Hadith viable. However, by the same token we can also reject the al Kafi tradition since the UMME KALTHUM in this tradition is not clarified that therefore renders her an unknown personality. And unlike even the Hadith in which Kunfuz is mentioned, there is not even a context to what is being said here. If Shah Abdul Aziz can use this argument to counter a Shi'a argument we are entitled to use his approach when countering a considerably weaker Nasibi argument.


Reply eight - Imam Ja'far al Sadiq (as) was referring to a distant relative



The word 'zaalik' is used in the tradition and in Arabic when one is referring to distance. In this tradition the Umme Kalthum (as) that Imam Ja'far al Sadiq (as) was referring to was far removed from the lineage of Rasulullah (s), had it referred to a close relative from Ahl'ul ul bayt (as) zaalik would not have been used. The Umme Kalthum that was not closely related to the Ahl'ul bayt (as) was Umme Kalthum binte Abu Bakr. We already established from Sunni sources in the previous chapter that Umar proposed to marry Umme Kalthum binte Abu Bakr and Ayesha accepted the proposal


Reply nine - The term Ghuzubna



Some Nasibi shall no doubt pick up on the term Ghuzubna that literally means taken / snatched. Applying the word in this context would clearly contradict logic, wisdom and the Shari'a it simply makes no sense, particularly when there is no evidence in history to suggest that Umme Kalthum binte Fatima was snatched. If the Nasibi are going to claim that the Shi'a embarrassed by this allege marriage are in effect suggesting that Umar kidnapped the daughter of Fatima (as) we should point out that the tradition fails to locate the birth of the UMME KALTHUM concerned, it does not mention who her parents were, and as we have already proven (and shall elaborate further) the alleged marriage of UMME KALTHUM binte Fatima (as) is replete with contradictions, whilst the traditions relating to Umar's marriage to UMME KALTHUM daughter of Abu Bakr compliment one another. It is common sense that we leave a matter that has contradictions and accept that which has consistency i.e. marriage to daughter of Abu Bakr - this was the matter that Imam al Sadiq (as) was referring to.

With this in mind, one needs to understand the context in which the Imam was speaking. If I say, "Today was a black day" - it does not mean that they sky outside was black - although it does literally, I am speaking in a context expressing a viewpoint, as the Imam had done. Ghazabna "taken" refers to the regret of the Imam (as) that the marriage of UMME KALTHUM daughter of Abu Bakr had been taken out of the hands of Imam 'Ali (as)'s hands. After Abu Bakr died Imam 'Ali (as) married his widow, her daughter (born after Abu Bakr died) was Kalthum. The marriage of UMME KALTHUM was arranged by Ayesha and Imam 'Ali (as) was not pleased with this, but Ayesha had a greater say as she was Abu Bakr's waris (executor) - Imam a' Sadiq (as)'s use of Ghuzubna was regret that this matter was taken away from Imam 'Ali (as).


Reply ten - the word Umme Kalthum (as)



If Afriki is going to insist that UMME KALTHUM automatically means binte 'Ali, then we ask those with logic:

If a woman is called Ayesha does that automatically mean that her husband is the son in law of a man called 'Abu Bakr? If a woman is called Hafsa does that automatically mean that her husband is the son in law of a man called Umar? Likewise you cannot conclude that if a woman is called Umme Kalthum, then her husbands' father in law is called 'Ali.


Reply eleven - a tradition that contradicts the Qur'an and Sunnah is to be rejected



This is a clear part of Sunni and Shi'a jurisprudence. The moment a tradition is in violation to the Qur'an and Sunnah it is to be discarded.

The Qur'an makes it clear that we are not to mix with those that are Zaalim - we deem Umar to be Zaalim on account of his treatment of Sayyida Fatima (as) as proven in chapter one. Marrying a Zaalim is ten times worse than liaising with one, and we are not prepared to accept that Imam 'Ali (as) would marry his daughter to a Zaalim since this would contradict the Qur'an.

In al Kafi there is a tradition that states clearly that if a tradition contradicts the Sunnah of Rasulullah (s) it must be rejected. We read in Riyadh al Nadira Volume 3 page 182 that Umar had asked for the hand of Sayyida Fatima (as) in marriage, Rasulullah (s) rejected his offer. This rejection made it clear that Umar was not eligible to marry a daughter of Rasulullah (s) this was his Sunnah. Sayyida Umme Kalthum (as) was also a daughter of Rasulullah (s), when rejecting Umar was a Sunnah of Rasulullah (s) then there is no way that Imam 'Ali (as) would contradict the established Sunnah.

Al Kafi Volume 1 page 68 also makes it clear that if any contradiction does indeed arise, then we are to reject those traditions that support Sunni aqeedah, hence if the Sunni viewpoint is that Umme Kalthum married Umar, we reject it.


Reply twelve - Use of the term "Furuj"



Afriki seeks to play a moralistic game:


Ansar.org states:
The word 'woman' here is an attempt from the writer of this article to preserve the honour of the Ahl al-Bayt, since a literal translation of the original Arabic would prove too vulgar.


There is no need for this Nasibi to try and preserve the honour of the Ahl'ul bayt (as) particularly when as cited in chapter one his Salaf Imams have done their utmost to destroy and humiliate the Ahl'ul bayt (as). Does this Nasibi really think he can use this moralistic line with us when his Ulema claim that Imam 'Ali (as) grooms his daughter, sends her to Umar's home, who kisses and fondles her. Are these traditions that preserve and honour the Ahl'ul bayt (as)?

This Nasibi needs to understand that Furuj can mean "sexual organ" but it also can mean "Chastity" and "Respect". If this Nasibi is going to suggest that we are lying and that this is an exclusive filthy term, then could he explain why Allah (swt) use the word Furuj when referring to Hadhrath Maryam? Allah (swt) says clearly in Surah al Anbiya verse 92:

"She protected her Furuj"

If Furuj is indeed always synonymous in Arabic as a vulgar term then why does Allah (swt) use it when praising such a pure / chaste woman?


Reply thirteen - The word "Furuj" has been used by Rasulullah (s) his wives in Sahih al Bukhari



We read in Sahih al Bukhari that Ayesha said:

Whenever the Prophet intended to sleep while he was Junub, he used to wash his private parts and perform ablution like that for the prayer.
Sahih al Bukhari Volume 1, Book 5, Number 286

Umm'ul Momineen Maimuna also uses the term Furuj.

This is proven from Sahih al Bukhari Volume 1, Book 5, Number 249:

"Narrated Maimuna:
(The wife of the Prophet) Allah's Apostle performed ablution like that for the prayer but did not wash his feet. He washed off the discharge from his private parts and then poured water over his body. He withdrew his feet from that place (the place where he took the bath) and then washed them. And that was his way of taking the bath of Janabah".


If Furuj is such a filthy term then why did Ayesha and Maimuna use it when talking about Rasulullah (s)? In Sahih al Bukhari "Chapter on Ghusl" Rasulullah's wives usage of the term Furuj can be located in SEVEN traditions. If wives can use it, then why is Afriki making a big issue if Imam al Sadiq (as) says the same?

We have cited the term Furuj from the most authentic text of Ahl'ul Sunnah. The fact is the term Furuj was common amongst Arabs at that particular time all because this term is not commonly used today in other countries (except in a vulgar context) do NOT automatically mean that it is incorrect to use it. Rather than attack the Shi'a for this word in al Kafi, it would be far better for Afriki to conduct an autopsy of the term Furuj in his own books, and he will see that this term is not just restricted to Sahih al Bukhari�


Reply fourteen - shooting stars appeared from the "Furuj" of Imam Shaafi's mother



We are quoting this reference from the following three esteemed works of Ahl'ul Sunnah.


  1. Tareekh Baghdad Volume 2 page 59 Dhikr Muhammad bin Shaafi
  2. Seerath al Halabeeya Volume 1 page 92 Dhikr Muhammad 'ur Rasulullah
  3. Isma al Rijjal - Dhikr Imam Shaafi page 41

"When our Imam Shaafi's mother was carrying him (in pregnancy) she saw a dream in which shooting stars were coming out of her Furuj, one fell in Egypt and then light encompassed all other cities. An interpreter of dreams told her and said 'Lady Khaleeda you shall give birth to a son whose knowledge shall reach Egypt in the first instance and then travel to all cities".

We should point out to our opponents that we have sited this reference referring to the Furuj of Shaafi's mother from your own esteemed works. In their efforts to praise Shaafi, his supporters did not even spare referring to the Furuj of Shaafi's mother. It is amusing that Afriki deems this terminology as vulgar, whilst for Shaafi' supporters this is a matter of pride�


Reply fifteen - Asma binte Abu Bakr's Furuj of mercy



We read in Habeeb as Sayyar Volume 2 page 23:

"When the news of Abdullah Ibn Zubayr's death reached his mother Asma binte Abu Bakr, she began to mourn. Despite her age of ninety she began to menstruate and said 'Allah's child, mercy be upon you, every part of my body is mourning you, including my Furuj that is reciting mercy for you.


Reply sixteen - The Ahl'ul Sunnah deem it permissible to spread Qur'anic verses over a woman's furuj



We read in Tafseer Durre Manthur, Volume 4 page 42, under the commentary of the last verse of Surah Yusuf as follows:

"Rasulullah (s) stated that if a woman feels the pangs of child birth, should bring a clean bowl and then place this [above] verse into a bowl. The bowl should then be washed and then this water should be administered to some trustworthy women to drink. Any water remaining should be sprinkled over the stomach and 'Furuj' [vagina]


Reply seventeen - The Hanafi Fiqh deem it permissible for a man to observe a woman's furuj during Salaat



In this regard we shall rely on the following esteemed work of the Hanafi Sect:


  1. Fatawa Alamgeeri Volume 1 page 143 Bab Salaat
  2. Fatawa Qadhi Khan Volume 1 page 64 Bab Salaat

We are quoting directly from Fatawa Qadhi Khan:

"If any man lustfully observes a woman's Furuj whilst offering Salaat then the woman's mother and daughter become haraam for him. If a man lustfully looks at the furuj of a woman that he had previously divorced, but who he can now lawfully take back then that woman shall remain Halal for him and his Salaat shall not become batil [void]".


Reply eighteen - the Hanafi litmus test to determine who should lead Salaat



The Hanafi madhab's authority work Durre Mukhthar Volume 1 page 42 states:

"When two Imams are present in a Mosque at one given time, the following criteria can be used to decided which Imam should lead the prayers:


  1. One whose wife is more beautiful
  2. One who has more possessions
  3. One whose prestige / persona is greater
  4. One whose clothes are cleaner
  5. One whose head is larger and penis is smaller"

Having cited these references we would like to point out to Mr Moralistic al Nasibi Afriki:

'when your books describe the following:


  • the Furuj of Imam Shaafi's mother,
  • the Furuj of Asma binte Abu Bakr,
  • the lawfulness of Hanafi men to lustfully observe a woman's furuj during salaat
  • the legitimacy of a pregnant woman to place a Qur'anic verse on her Furuj
  • the penis size criterion for Hanafi Imams

What right do you have to attack the use of Furuj in al Kafi?'


Reply nineteen - the rules of Nikah require the man and woman to be the kuff (equivalent) of one another



As proof we shall cite the following authority works of Ahl'ul Sunnah:


  1. Al Hidaya, Chapter Nikah fasl fi Kuf Volume 2 page 320
  2. Sharh wa Qaya Chapter "Nikah" page 100
  3. Durre Mukthar "Kitab Nikah" Volume 2 page 7
  4. A'zathu khufa Risala Fiqh Amr, Kitab Nikah, Dhikr Kuf Volume 3 page 407
  5. Fatawa Qadhi Khan, Kitab Nikah Volume 1 page 161
  6. Fiqh A'la Madhab al Arba "Kitab Nikah" Volume 4 page 54
  7. Al Hajr al Dukhair, Kitab Nikah Volume 3 page 48

We read in Fiqh A'la Madhab al Arba "Kitab Nikah" Volume 4 page 54:

"Kuf means that a man and woman are on equal standing, in certain criteria, namely:


  1. Ancestry
  2. Islam
  3. Family lineage
  4. Free (not captive)
  5. Respect
  6. Property and money

We read in Al Hajr al Dukhair, Kitab Nikah Volume 3 page 48:

"Kuf means that a man and woman piety and family lineage should be equal, this is a compulsory component of Nikah".

Also worthy of note is Umar's very own statement on this issue. Hanafi scholar Mufti Ghulam Rasul, cites Imam Muhammad's 'Al Ahsaf' wherein we read that:

"Hadhrath Umar Faruq (ra) stated 'I shall issue an edict that the Nikah of a woman from a family of high rank / social standing should not be conducted with one from a lower family".
Hasb aur Nasab, Vol.1 Page 40

These are the conditions of kuff in the eyes of Ahl'ul Sunnah. Islam is a comprehensive code of life, covering all aspects of living including behaviour such as manners and etiquette. The laws are clearly stipulated, as is the case for marriage. The Ulema of Ahl'ul Sunnah have clearly stipulated the concept of kuff, as a necessary component of Nikah, male and female should be on par with one another. We are prevented from marrying anyone who is not above or below our status, and not to contract marriages that are devoid of equality. Applying this to the Sunni assertion, how can an old man, with three wives, marry someone who had was only a mere child? We even have Umar's own comments on kuff. Was he such a hypocrite that he would advocate marriages based on equal ranking for other but ignore such a rule in his own case?

The Shi'a share the same views with the following additional criteria. The man must:


  1. Not be a Nasibi
  2. Must not drink alcohol
  3. Must not be illegitimate
  4. Must not be homosexual

If an individual possess these flaws he is prohibited from marrying a women of good / pure ancestry. Umar was NOT the kuff of Sayyida Umme Kalthum binte Fatima (as). She possessed a complete pure ancestry, whilst Umar was of unknown ancestry. Before expanding on this point it is necessary to expose the unknown ancestry of Waleed bin Mugheera as Rasulullah (s) had compared Umar to Waleed.


Waleed did not possess a legitimate ancestry



As our evidence we shall quote Verse 10-13 of the Pen and Paper in the Qur'an, wherein Allah (swt) exposes the flaws in Waleed's character including the fact that he was illegitimate. We are quoting from Abdullah Yusuf Ali's transliteration of the verses:

"Heed not the type of despicable men,- ready with oaths, A slanderer, going about with calumnies, (Habitually) hindering (all) good, transgressing beyond bounds, deep in sin, Violent (and cruel), with all that, base-born"


The Ahl'ul Sunnah Ulema are in agreement that this verse descended with regards to Waleed bin Mugheera and that base-born means of illegitimate birth



Proof of this fact can bee seen in the following classical works of Ahl'ul Sunnah:


  1. Tafseer Kabeer Volume 8 page 188
  2. Tafseer Mazhari Volume 10 page 34
  3. Tafseer Khazan Volume 7 page 110
  4. Tafseer Kashaf Volume page 485
  5. Tafseer Durre Manthur Volume 6 page 404
  6. Tafseer Ruh al Ma'ani Volume 3 pages 48-49
  7. Tafseer Jalalayn Volume 3 page 29
  8. Al Fathuwaath Volume 4 page 284

For the sake of brevity we shall cite only the one source, Al Fathuwaath Volume 4 page 284:

"When this verse descended, Waleed approached his mother and said, 'Muhammad cited my characteristics. I am fully aware of them with the exception of the final one (that I am illegitimate). Now if you do not tell me the truth, then I shall strike off your neck. Waleed's mother replied 'Your father was impotent, so I slept with another man and you are that man's son' "


In the eyes of Rasulullah (s) the example of Umar was the same as that of Waleed



As evidence for this fact we have relied on the following authentic texts of Ahl'ul Sunnah:


  1. Sifwaath an Sifwaath Volume 1 page 304, Dhikr Umar
  2. Al Tabaqal al Kabeer Volume 3 page 168, Dhikr Umar
  3. Tareekh al Khulafa Dhikr Umar page 111
  4. Sawaiqh al Muhriqa page 55
  5. Seerath al Halabeeya Volume 4 page 15
  6. Rauzathul Ahbaab Volume 1 page 134
  7. Riyadh al Nadira page 60 - Part 2 Dhikr Umar
  8. Nur al Absar page 60

This event is narrated similarly in the above named books and for the sake of brevity we shall quote just Sifwaath an Sifwaath, Volume 1, page 304, under Dhikr Umar:

"When Hadhrath Umar went to slay Rasulullah (s) with his sword, he (s) had received information of this and he stood up and took hold of his collar saying, "'Umar, why do you not desist from this action? Will you not refrain lest Allah (swt) reveals that information about you that He has already revealed about Waleed bin Mugheera?"


Questions about ancestry put before Rasulullah (s), and Umar's concerns



We read in Sahih al Bukhari, "Book of knowledge" Volume 1, Book 3, Number 93:

"Narrated Anas bin Malik:
One day Allah's Apostle came out (before the people) and 'Abdullah bin Hudhafa stood up and asked (him), "Who is my father?" The Prophet replied, "Your father is Hudhafa." The Prophet told them repeatedly (in anger) to ask him anything they liked. 'Umar knelt down before the Prophet and said thrice, "We accept Allah as (our) Lord and Islam as (our) religion and Muhammad as (our) Prophet." After that the Prophet became silent".


We relied on eight esteemed Ahl'ul Sunnah works to demonstrate that when Umar went to kill Rasulullah (s) with his sword, his action was like that of Waleed bin Mugheera who threatened to slay his mother, upon receiving the news of his illegitimacy, a fact that was subsequently vouched for by his mother. Rasulullah (s) had similarly warned 'Umar, pointing out that he was fully aware that he was in receipt of the same information on him as had been revealed about Waleed bin Mugheera, and that unless he desisted from his violent actions and attempt to assassinate the Seal of Prophets (saws), Allah (swt) would certainly cause a verse to be revealed about 'Umar as it had about Walid. Both individuals assumed that they had legitimate ancestry and both were incorrect in their assumption.

We should not be surprised by this, indeed we should be surprised when a Sahaba is of legitimate birth, for debauchery was prevalent and accepted as common and matter-of-fact in the pre-Islamic days of Jahiliya�we have the example of illegitimacy being common in western societies in our own time, and the people of the time of Jahiliya were not even People of the Book. The shock of some muslims at this notion, that many of the Sahaba were, in all likelihood of illegitimate birth, is based upon romanticisation within Sunni Islam. If a man is illegitimate but has good actions then his illegitimacy confers upon him few disadvantages except in the matter of kuff and khilafat, and he is to be regarded as his actions determine, not on what his parents did. But, with the illegitimacy of the time we must also remember that it was also associated with bad actions on the part of the illegitimate offspring. Many of the Sahaba had, in fact, been both illegitimate and also Jahils�.Umar so Jahil that he had dared to try and assassinate the Holy Prophet (saws).

On the basis of this evidence, and Ahl'ul Sunnah aqeedah that a marriage has to be based on kuff between the man and woman (that this is a necessary component of marriage), we can conclude that 'Umar could not have been married to Umm Kalthum (as) the daughter of Ali (as) and Fatima (as). 'Umar was illegitimate, while Umm Kalthum (as) was the granddaughter of the Holy Prophet (saws). There is no equivalence, in any way, between them in terms of kuff. Illegitimacy has implications in Shari'a - an illegitimate man cannot be a rightly guided khalifa (Al Mawardi, Al Ahkam Al Sultaniya). Thus we can question whether 'Umar was rightly guided as a khalifa. BUT we can also question whether 'Ali (as) would have given his daughter's hand in marriage to an illegitimate man, while she was the granddaughter of the Holy Prophet (saws).

On this basis alone we can conclude that the marriage of Umme Kalthum binte 'Ali (as) and Fatima (as) to 'Umar ibn al Khattab would have been haram. Sayyida Umme Kalthum (as) was a woman with the pure / noble ancestry of Banu Hashim, while 'Umar's unknown ancestry automatically means that she was not the kuff (equivalent) of Umar. We are not prepared to accept that Maula 'Ali (as) contravened the Shari'a by marrying his daughter to a man who was not her equivalent. If any text contradicts this assertion (and confirms such a marriage) then the fault lies with the narrators not with the actions of Ahl'ul bayt (as).

Some Nasibi will no doubt pose the question that if Umar was devoid of legitimate ancestry, why would Rasulullah (s) refer to him as Ibn al Khattab. Our reply shall be based on two proofs:

We read in the Qur'an that False Gods are called "I la" that is Allah (swt)'s actual name.

Verily ye, (unbelievers), and the (false) gods that ye worship besides Allah, are (but) fuel for Hell! to it will ye (surely) come!
Surah al Anbiya verse 99

Ibrahim (as) calls a star "Rub" - again Allah's exclusive title.

When the night covered him over, He saw a star: He said: "This is my Lord." But when it set, He said: "I love not those that set. When he saw the moon rising in splendour, he said: "This is my Lord." But when the moonset, He said: "unless my Lord guide me, I shall surely be among those who go astray. When he saw the sun rising in splendour, he said: "This is my Lord; this is the greatest (of all)."
Surah Anam verses 67-69

We ask Afriki, when an idol is not Allah (swt), nor is the star, sun or moon then why have all four been given the titles "I la" and "Rabb"? The fact is, when a title becomes commonplace then it becomes perfectly acceptable to use that terminology. The word "I la" and "Rabb" whilst being used to describe an idol, the star, sun and moon has clearly been used by Allah (swt) because these were commonly held terms used for all four, as used by the Arabs of that time. Similarly, Umar's birth in the home of Khattab meant that the indigenous Arab population referred to him as Ibn Khattab. This is common sense, a person that raises a child in his home, will be deemed by the outside world as that child's father, the fact that Khattab raised Umar lead to him being popularly known by his father'' name. In the same way that Waleed was referred to as Ibn Mugheera, Umar was called Ibn Khattab.


Reply twenty - It is not permissible to marry a momin daughter to a Nasibi



As proof we present to hadith from our most esteemed Shi'a source Furu al Kafi Volume 5 page 349, Kitab al Nikah. Both hadith are on the authority of Imam Ja'far al Sadiq (as):

"Do not marry a momin daughter to a Nasibi"

(The narrator asked the Imam) 'Is it permissible to marry one's daughter to a Nasibi? Imam (as) replied, to marry one's daughter to a Nasibi is neither acceptable nor halaal".


This may be a bitter pill for the followers of Mu'awiya to swallow, but Umar was a Nasibi (one who hates Ahl'ul bayt (as)). This can be proven via his actions. His behaviour towards Sayyida Fatima (as), his threat to burn her home without caring for her feelings, his assault on her that led to a miscarriage and her insistence that he should not attend her funeral are clear proofs that he was a Nasibi.

When Imam al Sadiq (as) has stated that one should not marry one's daughter to a Nasibi then there is no way that Imam 'Ali (as) would marry his daughter to one. The descendants of Rasulullah (s) unlike the descendants of Mu'awiya and Marwan always practised what they preached. Tell us Afriki, if someone:


  • Threatened to harm your wife by setting her home on fire whilst she was inside,
  • Pained you wife so much that she issued an instruction that he not attend her funeral in the event of her death, would you then marry your daughter to that same individual? We do not believe that ANY man would stoop so low, and yet these Nasibi are trying to convince us that Imam 'Ali (as) had done just that.


Reply twenty first - Do not marry your daughter to a man that possesses bad manners



We are citing our esteemed Shi'a source Waseeyath ul Najaath page 300, Chapter Nikah:

"Rasulullah (s) said 'Do not marry your daughter to man that possesses bad manners"


Umar possessed bad manners



We read in Sahih al Bukhari Volume 5, Book 57, Number 32, Chapter Companions of the Prophet:

"Narrated Sad bin Abi Waqqas:
Umar bin Al-Khattab asked the permission of Allah's Apostle to see him while some Quraishi women were sitting with him, talking to him and asking him for more expenses, raising their voices above the voice of Allah's Apostle.
When 'Umar asked for the permission to enter, the women quickly put on their veils. Allah'� Apostle allowed him to enter and 'Umar came in while Allah's Apostle was smiling, 'Umar said "O Allah's Apostle! May Allah always keep you smiling." The Prophet said, "These women who have been here, roused my wonder, for as soon as they heard your voice, they quickly put on their veils. "'Umar said, "O Allah's Apostle! You have more right to be feared by them than I." Then 'Umar addressed the women saying, "O enemies of yourselves! You fear me more than you do Allah's Apostle?" They said, "Yes, for you are harsher and sterner than Allah's Apostle." Then Allah's Apostle said, "O Ibn Al-Khattab! By Him in Whose Hands my life is! Never does Satan find you going on a way, but he takes another way other than yours".



The Sahaba of Rasulullah (s) were tired of Umar's bad manners



As evidence we shall cite the following texts:


  1. Asad ul Ghaybah Volume 4 page 168 Dhikr Umar
  2. Al Tabaqat Ibn Sa'd Volume 3 page 199 "Waseeyath Abu Bakr"
  3. Tareekh Tabari Volume 4 page 2137 "The events of 13 Hijri"
  4. Tareekh Kamil Volume 3 page 207
  5. Al Imama wa al Siyasa page 19 "Dhikr Wafaath Abi Bakr"

"When Abu Bakr nominated Umar to succeed him, the Sahaba approached him, complaining of Umar's bad manners, they said 'What response will you give to Allah (swt) when He (swt) asks you 'Why did you appoint Umar, when you was aware that he is a bad mannered individual?"
Al Imama wa al Siyasa page 19


Imam 'Ali (as) did not even wish to see Umar's face on account of his bad manners



We are just quoting partially from what is a very lengthy narration in Sahih al Bukhari Volume 5, Book 59, Number 546 "Chapter Military Expeditions led by the Prophet (pbuh) (Al-Maghaazi). Ayesha narrates:

"�When Fatima was alive, the people used to respect 'Ali much, but after her death, 'Ali noticed a change in the people's attitude towards him. So Ali sought reconciliation with Abu Bakr and gave him an oath of allegiance. 'Ali had not given the oath of allegiance during those months (i.e. the period between the Prophet's death and Fatima's death). 'Ali sent someone to Abu Bakr saying, "Come to us, but let nobody come with you," as he disliked that 'Umar should come."

In summary these references prove that Umar possessed bad manners, this was made clear before Rasulullah (s) by the Quraysh women, and Rasulullah (s) corroborated their claim stating that even Satan flees from him on account of his behaviour. When Abu Bakr made Umar his successor, the Sahaba expressed their concerns that Umar was bad mannered. Imam 'Ali (as) did not even wish to see the face of Umar due to his bad manners. The Shari'a, as set out by Rasulullah (s) makes it clear that one should not marry a man with bad manners. We already established in Chapter one, that Amr bin Aas did not want Umar to marry Umme Kalthum binte Abu Bakr on account of his bad manners, and the books of Ahl'ul Sunnah confirm that the same Umme Kalthum had rejected this proposal on account of Umar's bad manners, Ayesha also initially rejected the proposal on this same ground.

Ayesha and Amr bin Aas may well have given in to Umar's assurances, but Imam 'Ali (as) would certainly not have, he would never had married his beloved daughter to a bad mannered man, particularly in light of the suffering this bad mannered man had exposed his wife to.


Reply twenty second - it is not permissible for a father to marry his daughter to a man that drinks alcohol



We read in the Shi'a text Furu al Kafi Volume 5, page 347, Kitab Nikah:



"Imam Ja'far al Sadiq (as) said "Anyone that marries his daughter to a man that drinks alcohol had done an injustice to her. Rasulullah (s) had deemed alcohol to be haraam, so if an individual drinks (alcohol) do not marry your daughters to him".


Umar used to drink alcohol



We read in Ahl'ul Sunnah's authority work "al Mustaraf fi kul Mustadhruf Volume 2 page 229, Chapter 74 the following:

"Three verses were revealed by Allah (swt) in connection with the prohibition on alcohol. In regards to alcohol people asked questions on it to Rasulullah (s), who replied that it was a great sin. After some time, some Muslims began to refrain from drinking alcohol, whilst others continued to drink it, this got to a point whereby on one occasion a man entered the Mosque and proceeded to speak nonsense during Salaat. It was at this time that the verse descended "O you believe do not approach prayers whilst intoxicated. Some people then left alcohol, whilst others continued to drink, to the point that Umar drank alcohol, mounted onto a camel and then proceeded to throw an object at Abdul Rahman bin Auf, that caused his head to split open, he then began to sing about the kuffar participant of Badr. His actions reached a point of kufr and transgression, he (Umar) began to say 'I won't fast in Ramadan, and you cannot stop me from drinking. When Rasulullah (s) received news of this, he left the mosque and hit Umar on the head with an object, it was then that this verse descended 'Satan wants you to stop�' Umar then said 'Yes I have stopped, I have stopped'.
Also:
Al-Mustathraf Fi-Kule Fane Muthathraf, Page 469-470

The Shari'a prohibits a woman from marrying a man that drinks, and we have relied an esteemed work of Ahl'ul Sunnah that identifies Umar as being so drunk that he began to sing the praises of the kuffar of Badr. Would Imam 'Ali (as) marry his daughter to such an individual?


Umar used to keep alcohol in his water flask



We read in Ahl'ul Sunnah authority commentary of Sahih al Bukhari, Fathul Bari Volume 5 page 341 that:

"On one occasion Saeed bin Zai drank from Umar's water flask and he became intoxicated. Umar began to beat him and Saeed said to him 'My only wrongdoing was that I drank from your flask'. (Upon hearing this) Umar replied 'I am beating you, as I want to know why you became intoxicated".

This reference proves that Umar would keep alcohol in his water flask and it compliments a narration by Al-Nakha`i wherein we learn that `Umar during latter part of his reign drank alcoholic wine (nabidh) which he diluted with water, saying: "Do this if/lest its shaytan overcome you"
see al-Sarakhsi's al-Mabsut, book of beverages, chapter on Muzara`at al-Harbi; and I`la' al-Sunan (18:34)

We do not doubt that the water flask was mixed with water, but clearly poor Saeed's experience proves that that the alcohol was of such strength that an ordinary man that drank from the flask would be unable to tolerate it and immediately become intoxicated. Clearly this was not the case for Umar, as he was used to consuming such strong alcohol, which is why he could not understand why taking just one drink had intoxicated Saeed.


Hadhrath Umar's love of 'Nabidh' alcohol



Nabidh is a drink that is prepared by fermenting crushed dates / grapes. It was Hadhrath Umar's favourite alcoholic drink.

We read in Muwatta of Imam Malik, Book 45, Number 45.6.21, Chapter Madina:

Yahya related to me from Malik from Yahya ibn Said from Abd ar-Rahman ibn al-Qasim that Aslam, the mawla of Umar ibn al-Khattab informed him that he had visited Abdullah ibn Ayyash al-Makhzumi. He saw that he had some nabidh with him and he was at that moment on the way to Makka. Aslam said to him, ''Umar ibn al-Khattab loves this drink." Abdullah ibn Ayyash therefore carried a great drinking bowl and brought it to Umar ibn al-Khattab and placed it before him. Umar brought it near to him and then raised his head. Umar said, "This drink is good," so he drank some of it and then passed it to a man on his right".


Umar drank Nabidh alcohol on his deathbed



We are quoting from Ahl'ul Sunnah's classical work Riyadh al Nadira Volume 2 page 351:

"Whilst on his deathbed, Umar became deeply affected by the wound and his physician asked Umar 'Which alcohol would you like to drink?' Umar said 'alcohol called nabidh is my preferred choice. This drink was then administered to Umar".
Riyadh al Nadira Volume 2 page 351

There is no way that Ahl'ul Sunnah can claim that 'Nabidh' does not constitute alcohol, since Rasulullah (s) had specifically referred to this as haraam. We read in Sunan Abu Daud Book 26, Number 3707:

"Narrated Abu Hurayrah:
I knew that the Apostle of Allah (saww) used to keep fast. I waited for the day when he did not fast to present him the drink (nabidh), which I made in a pumpkin. I then brought it to him while it fermented. He said: Throw it to this wall, for this is a drink of the one who does not believe in Allah and the Last Day".


Our opponents should examine the text that says clearly that Umar had requested "Nabidh". It is unfortunate that even on his deathbed the second Khalifa's thoughts were on drinking alcohol. Umar's alcoholic way, even until his deathbed means that under the Shari'a it would have not have been permissible for Imam 'Ali (as) to marry his daughter to Umar.


Reply twenty third - do not marry your daughter to a 'Mukhnaath'



We are quoting from the authority of the Shi'a work Waseelathul Najaath, page 300, Chapter Kitab Nikah:
"Do not marry your daughter to a man that possess the following flaws:

  1. He is bad mannered
  2. He is mukhnaath
  3. He is a transgressor
  4. He drinks alcohol"


The definition of Mukhnaath



To shed light on this definition we shall rely on Ahl'ul Sunnah's authority work "Kitab al Lughat al Hadeeth" Volume 2, page 141, by Allamah Wahid az Zaman:


"We do not deem it permissible to offer Salat behind a Mukhnaath. Qasthalani stated that Mukhnaath is a person that indulges in sodomy".


Three individuals were identified as Mukhnaath during the early part of Rasulullah's mission



We read in Tafseer Ruh-al Maani, Volume 3 page 49 under the commentary of "Surah Pen and Paper"

"This verse refers to the filthy act of Zeenum. Ibn Abi Hathim stated that "Zeenam is that person who takes it in the anus, and in this verse three individuals are referred, Waleed bin Mughira, Hakim bin Aas, Abu Jahal".

For those interested in reading to this matter, the Ahl'ul Sunnah text Hayaath al Haywaan discussed the homosexuality of Hakim and Abu Jahal. Sawaiqh al Muhriqa also acknowledges that Hakim was a homosexual, but that this came to an end when he attained the rank of Sahaba. Our interest is with regards to Waleed bin Mugheera since Rasulullah (s) had compared Waleed to Hadhrath Umar.

We have faithfully cited this reference from Tafseer Ruh al Ma'ani, which is a high-ranking Sunni Tafseer, which cited the comments of Ibn Hatim who was an esteemed Sunni scholar. Ibn Khalikkan in Wafaat al Wafayaat Volume 1 page 543 (Egypt edition) wrote as follows:

"Abdur Rahman al Muhammad Ibn Abi Hatim al Timmeemee al Handhali stated that the son of an Imam is an Imam and the son of a Hafidh is also a Hafidh. Abu'l Ali Khlalilee stated that the above individual was at the forefront of servants, his piety, knowledge and wisdom had been praised by the majority".


Allah (swt) had unveiled Waleed's actions, and was threatening to reveal that same about Umar



We are quoting from the following three authority texts of Ahl'ul Sunnah:


  1. Sifwaat al Safwaat Volume 1 page 103 Dhikr Umar
  2. Riyadh al Nadira Volume 2 page 11 Dhikr Islam, Umar
  3. Al Tabaqat al Kubra Urdu translation, Volume 3, Page 58

All three texts record this momentous event as follows:

"When Umar went to kill Rasulullah (s) with his sword, Rasulullah (s) grabbed him and said ''Umar, will you not desist from this action, lest Allah reveals the same bad news about you that He revealed about Waleed bin Mugheera?"
Al Tabaqat al Kubra Urdu translation, Volume 3, Page 58

With regards to Waleed bin Mugheera we have proved from Ahl'ul Sunnah's Ruh al Ma'ani that he was a homosexual, and a verse had been revealed exposing his filthy acts. Rasulullah (s) had similarly warned Umar to control himself, otherwise a verse would also descend about him as had been revealed about Mugheera. From here we can deduce that according to Sunni scholars, 'Umar indulged in sodomy in the same way that Waleed bin Mugheera did. Rasulullah (s) had compared them both on account of their similar virtues, they were one and the same. At first, the fact that such Sahaba may have been homosexuals may come as a surprise.

Again, as with the issue of illegitimacy, it may be nothing but a product of the romanticisation of them. The people of Jahiliya who Mohammad (saws) had to contend with, who were now many of the Sahaba, including most of the Muhajireen from Makka, had been worse than the people of Sodom that Hadhrath Lut (as) (The Prophet Lot) had to do contend with. Since they were worse than the Sodomites, it is not surprising that their own well-known addiction to the flesh and carnal desires meant that homosexuality too would have been rampant. Undoubtedly, the modern Western world is a model of the days of Jahiliya, and likewise we see in the modern world the resurgence of homosexuality, which in many western countries is considered normal behaviour, or nothing but a trifle. Indeed, men who hold power at the highest levels of today's governments, power comparable to that which 'Umar and other Sahaba held, are under the influence of this affliction and are tolerated in western societies where they are part of the ruling class.

Whatever conditions / illnesses that people suffer from, Allah (swt) has provided a cure, and it is left for man to search out such cures. In this regard, people should not feel aggrieved by homosexuality, for there is forgiveness if the perpetrator sincerely repents after one warning, though not after the second when he must be executed. May Allah (swt) reward the family of Sunni Hakeems, such as that of Hakeem Ajmul Khan, for their efforts to treat this affliction. Hakeems are men of religious training who specialise in the practice of 'Islamic' medicine, as opposed to 'western' medicine. A few exist to this day. The father of the late Hakeem Ajmul Khan, Hakeem Shareef Khan Dehlavi had prescribed the treatment for this condition in his book "Ahlaaj al Mareez" Part 8, Dialogue 14 page 309.

This book was in the book collection of Hakeem Ajmul Khan's grandson, Hakeem Mahmood Khan. The book then reached the hands of his student Dr Sayyid Shareef Husayn Dehlavi of Luknow. Hakeem Mahmood states that on the 13th of October 1890 he saw with his own eyes the following text from "Ahlaaj al Mareez" that he then copied into his own book of debates Thanzeey al Nasab page 80 under the Chapter "Rafidi ba Rafidi":

"The medicine that is needed to treat anal diseases was used extensively by the second khalifa, this medicine is prepared by grinding certain chemicals and then preparing a solution in either vinegar or wine and is then inserted into the anus of the patient"

However, while Islam is humanitarian enough to offer treatment to those whose anuses have been violated and abused by this unnatural practice, the Shari'a strictly prohibits marriage to a man that indulges in such anal practices and Islam condemns this type of person, Allah (swt) calling homosexuality an abomination in the Qur'an. We do not believe that any sincere muslim parent would marry their daughter to such an individual, and it is indeed deeply insulting to entertain the thought that Imam 'Ali (as) would marry his daughter to a man with homosexual tendencies, as was, according to certain Sunnis, the case with 'Umar.

While this supposed 'Sunna' or 'Practice' of 'Umar undoubtedly exists as a school of thought, one that lies just beneath the surface in acceptable Sunni muslim society (you don't have to probe very far beyond the surface of 'official' behaviour in many muslim countries to find this widespread belief and the practices that it is used to sanction by corrupt scholars), it has probably survived to this day to serve and to justify the homosexuality of numerous khalifas and even contemporary men of power, with the logic that if it was good enough for 'Umar it's good enough for you, so you can continue with your addiction to men. In this context it is further interesting to note that in Arabic, the words Ilat-e-Oonba are often used to describe homosexuality�literally it means an addiction (Ilat) to the anus (Oonba).

This suggests that men who practice homosexuality find it very difficult to give up, for with many it is an addiction like smoking. However, such an attitude is a distortion of the Qur'an and true Islam which expressly forbids homosexuality. The Sunni belief that 'Umar was homosexual appeases homosexual muslim men, reducing their guilt, and enables them to continue with their addiction. It lets them deceive themselves that they are not going to burn in Hell for their 'addiction'. The implicit words of the Qur'an which forbid this practice are ignored or twisted out of context, or not mentioned all, in favour of the 'Sunna' of 'Umar.

In short, it is impossible that a woman from such the pure / chaste family of Rasulullah (s) would be married to such an individual. The marriage just didn't happen. Thus, a further evidence against it happening is the fact that a school of Sunni thought accepts 'Umar as a homosexual. Thus he could not have married the daughter of 'Ali (as).


Reply twenty fourth - Rasulullah (s) had stated that the daughters of his household were to marry within the Banu Hashim



Imam of Ahl'ul Sunnah Ibn Hajr al Makki records in Sawaiqh al Muhriqa page160:

"Rasulullah (s) said, 'The women of household are reserved for the men of our household' we can conclude from this hadith that that the kuff of Banu Hashim is not a non-Hashmi".

This hadith is even more explicit in Shi'a references, where Rasulullah (s) had made a specific reference to the daughters of Sayyida Fatima (as), Shaykh Saduq narrates the following hadith in 'Mun la yuzul Faqih, Volume 3 page 249':

"Rasulullah (s) looked at the family of Ja'far Tayyar and Muhammad bin Ja'far Tayyar, and then looked at Hasan, Hussain, Zaynab and Kalthum and said 'Our daughters are for our sons and our sons are for our daughters'.

This hadith demonstrates that Rasulullah (s) had restricted marriage of his grand daughter (s) in his family. Rasulullah (s) clearly deemed the kuff of his daughter (s) to be restricted to his relatives. This being the case then how can it be believed that Imam 'Ali (as) would blatantly disregard the words of Rasulullah (s) and marry Umme Kalthum (as) to Umar who was non Hashmi and not even remotely her equivalent in marriage? Of interest if the fact that Ibn Qutaybah in al Maarif page 70 states:

"All of the daughters of Hadhrath 'Ali were married into the sons of Hadhrath Aqeel and Hadhrath Abbas, with the exception of Umm'ul Hasan and Fatima".

Why did Ibn Qutaybah fail to mention Umme Kalthum here?


Reply twenty fifth - Sayyida Zeyneb (as)'s strict interpretation of kuff could not have been maintained if her sister had married Umar



For this section we shall rely on both Sunni and Shi'a sources:

Shi'a References:


  1. Munthahil Aamaal, Volume 1 pages 432 - 433 (Iran)Shaykh Abbas Qummi
  2. Nufs'ul Mahamoon page 447 (Iran)
  3. Majalis page 31 by Shaykh Saduq Amali
  4. Rozhathul Waizoon page 164

Sunni references:


  1. Tarikh Kamil, Volume 4 page 35
  2. Tarikh Tabari Volume 19 page 171 (English translation by I.K.A Howard)

All the above sources record this event similarly, we are quoting from Tabari, where one of Imam 'Ali (as)'s daughters narrates the suffering of the women of Ahl'ul bayt (as) when they were presented before Imam of Ahl'ul Sunnah Yazid ibn Mu'awiya:

"Then a Syrian with a red face stood up before Yazid and said, 'Commander of the Faithful, give me this one'. He meant me. I was a pretty young girl. I shuddered and moved away, for I though that that would be allowed them. I caught hold of the skirt of my sister Zaynab. My sister Zaynab was older and cleverer than I. She said that that would not happen. She said to the Syrian, "By God! You are a liar! You are too lowly born! Such a thing is not for you, not for him!' Yazid cried out angrily, 'By God! You are a liar! That is for me. If I wish to do it I can do it'. She retorted, 'No by God! God would only let you do that if you left our faith and professed belief in another religion".

So here the reference makes it clear that:


  • The cursed Syrian wanted to marry one of Imam 'Ali (as)'s daughters
  • Sayyida Zeyneb (as) says that this could not be possible as he was lowly born (i.e. Not her kuff)
  • Sayyida Zeyneb stated that one who entered into such an action was a kaffir.

Hanafi scholar Mufti Ghulam Rasul commenting on this event states:

"This incident serves as proof that a Sayyida cannot be the kuff of a non Sayyid. This is why Sayyida Zeyneb said to Yazeed the cursed 'You should have some respect, these are the daughters of Rasulullah (s), no one has the right to decide that this girl is for me. This is the Sunnah of Ahl'ul bayt, on the issue of kuff, if one even contemplates such a thing he is outside the pale of Islam"
Hasab aur Nasab Volume 2 page 186

Now our question to Afriki is simple, how could Sayyida Zeyneb (as) maintain this strict rigid stance on kuff if we are to indeed to accept your account that her younger sister married Umar? Why did not a single individual in Yazid's court intervene and seek to correct Sayyida Zeyneb (as) and point out that her claim was baseless as her sister Umme Kalthum (as) was the widow of Umar?


Reply twenty sixth - The isnad of this narration



Whilst we are confident that these replies serve as sufficient proof within themselves, we would also like to make some comments on the isnad of this narration that Afriki claimed was Sahih. This Nasibi tactically avoids commenting the authenticity of the narrators. The chain is as follows:


Ansar.org states:
'Ali ibn Ibrahim-from his father-from Ibn Abi 'Umayr-from Hisham ibn Salim and Hammad-from Zurarah, who narrates that


Curiously when it comes to proving the isnad Afriki applies deception:


Ansar.org states:
NARRATION 1
al-Kulayni received the reports from Ibn Abi 'Umayr through his teacher 'Ali ibn Ibrahim ibn Hashim al-Qummi, who is his source for about one third of the material in al-Kafi. 'Ali ibn Ibrahim is the author of an early Tafsir of the Shi'ah, and is highly regarded by Shi'i rijal critics such as an-Najashi and Ibn Mutahhar, who declare him to be "thiqatun fil hadith, thabt, mu'tamad, sahih al-madhhab" (reliable in hadith transmission, reliable dependable, correct in belief.) (Jami' ar-Ruwat vol. 1 p. 545)

'Ali ibn Ibrahim al-Qummi reports from his father Ibrahim ibn Hashim al-Qummi. He is reputed to have been the first to spread the hadith of the Shi'ah from Kufah to Qum. Reports via him abound in al-Kafi, through his son. He has been generally accepted by the Shi'ah as a reliable narrator. He is even mentioned by Abu Ja'far at-Tusi as having met the 9th Imam. (Jami' ar-Ruwat vol. 1 p. 38) His reliability as a narrator is attested to in a contemporary work on the authority of his son, Ali ibn Ibrahim, Ibn Tawus and al-'Allamah al-Hilli. (Abu Talib at-Tajlil at-Tabrizi, Mu'jam ath-Thiqat, p. 5)

Ibrahim ibn Hashim al-Qummi reports on the authority of Muhammad ibn Abi 'Umayr. This Ibn Abi 'Umayr is one of the most reliable Shi'i narrators ever. Abu Ja'far at-Tusi says of him: "kana min awthaq an-nas" (he was of the most reliable of people). (al-Fihrist p. 169) More importantly, he was of the elect group of Shi'i narrators called the Ashab al-Ijma' (Men of the Consensus). What this means is that when the chain of narration is proven authentic up to one of these men, the rest of the chain up to the Imam may automatically be assumed to be authentic too. (See the details of this consensus in al-Mamaqani, Miqbas al-Hidayah fi 'Ilm ad-Dirayah, vol. 2 pp. 17 1-208) The authenticity of this narration is therefore proven on grounds of this consensus.


There are six narrators in this tradition and yet Afriki as his proof only cites three. One of the narrators of this hadith is Hisham ibn Salim. Worthy of note is Hisham is a narrator in three out of the four Shi'a traditions that Afriki cited from al Kafi. Afriki portrays Hisham as reliable by stating:


Ansar.org states:
Hisham ibn Salim is credited with having been a student of Imam Ja'far as-Sadiq. His reliability as a transmitter of hadith is attested to by the emphatic statement of al-'Allamah and an-Najashi: "thiqatun thiqah" (reliable, and once again reliable). (Jami' ar-Ruwat, vol. 2 p. 315)


If Afriki really wants to convince the Shi'a his first approach, then he should cite our MOST AUTENTIC book of Rijjal, which is not Jami' ar Ruwat but Rijjal al Kashi. When we want to know the authenticity of a narrator this is our first port of call. When we examine Rijjal al Kashi we learn that:

"He (Hisham) was an adherent of the "fasid al aqeedah" and believed that you physically see Allah (swt)"
Rijjal Kashi page 184

The fasid al aqeedah is a break away group from the Shi'a and their beliefs were so deviant that they opposed mainstream Shi'aism. The Shi'a concept of Allah (swt) is that He (swt) cannot be seen / has no physical attributes and to believe otherwise is kufr. Anyone that holds a viewpoint that He (swt) can be seen has deviated from the Shi'a path and hence any hadith narrated by him is to be rejected.

We have provided 26 replies to Afriki's claim that the tradition from al Kafi proved that Umme Kalthum binte Fatima (as) married Umar ibn al Khattab. We could provided many more but feel that at this stage this shall suffice to convince those who wish to know the truth - namely that this marriage was a lie and that Afriki had sought to deceptively read in between the lines of a vague Shi'a hadith to prove his point. We countered it pointing out that this marriage would have breached the Shari'a in Sunni and Shi'a eyes and hence simply did not happen.

Elucidation to the truth

So who was Umme Kalthum wife of Umar?



An analysis of the Ahl'ul Sunnah traditions makes it clear that the Umme Kalthum being described was a child (Sagheera) so young that she was still milk fed (Sabeeya) - this Umme Kalthum could not have been more than five years of age, at the time of marriage in 17 Hijri. Umme Kalthum binte Fatima (as) as we have already discussed was 11 / 12 years of age in 17 Hijri and hence was baligh - and according to Afriki's own admission was of marriageable age - she could not be described as Sabeeya or Sagheera - as was the status of Umar's wife in 17 Hijri.


Umar had several wives called Umme Kalthum



History establishes that Umar had several wives called Umme Kalthum:


  1. Umme Kalthum Jameela binte Asim bin Thabit - the mother of Asim bin Umar.
    (Tareekh Khamees Volume 2 page 251).

  2. Umme Kalthum binte Jarweela Khuzeema - Her actual name was Maleeka. She was the mother of Zaid bin Umar.
    (Tareekh Kamil Volume 3 page 22).

  3. Umme Kalthum binte Ukba bin Abi Mayyath - Zuhri narrates that during the period of jahiliyya she was the wife of Amr bin Aas. She left him and embraced Islam. Her relatives approached Rasulullah (s) and asked that she be returned. Rasulullah (s) replied 'Any woman that embraces Islam cannot be returned, Amr bin Aas was a kaffir at the time, she was not returned and Umar married her.
    (Sharh Bukhari, by Qasthalani Volume 4 page 349).

  4. Umme Kalthum binte Rahab.
    (Sunan Abu Daud and Ibn Majah)

  5. Umme Kalthum binte Abu Bakr - Born to Asma binte Umais. She was also the mother of Muhammad bin Abu Bakr. (Alam al Nisa Volume 4 page 250). She was born in 12 Hijri, after the death of Abu Bakr (Tabari Volume 2 page 50; Tareekh Kamil Volume 2 page 161; Tareekh Khamees Volume 2 page 267; al Isaba page 286) Asma married Imam 'Ali (as) and the young Umme Kalthum joined her mother in the house of Imam 'Ali (as).
    Sunni research scholar Malik Daulath Abadi in "Hidayaath al Saud" page 359 states:

"Asma binte Amees was initially the wife of Ja'far bin Tayyar then she married Abu Bakr from this relationship two children were born a boy and a girl called Umme Kalthum. After that she married Hadhrath 'Ali and Umme Kalthum came into his house. This is the Umme Kalthum that Umar married�she died at a young age, whilst residing in the house of Umar. She left no children".

Worthy of note is the fact that die-hard Deobandi and enemy of the Shi'a Allamah Doust Muhammad Quraishi in his article 'WHO WAS HADHRAT ALI RADHIALLAHU-ANHU)?' also admitted that:

"89. For the upbringing of the orphan Muhammad bin Abu Bakr (RA), Hadrath Ali (RA) married his mother Asma binte Umais (RA)".

Here is the link:
Jamiat.org.za/isinfo/aliwho.html

We shall Inshallah expand on this whole matter in greater depth in the next chapter. Suffice it to say for the moment, Asma married Imam 'Ali and the young Umme Kalthum (as) was in the home of Imam 'Ali (as) she was viewed as Umme Kalthum binte 'Ali. In 17 Hijri she would have been 5 years of age and would was indeed Sagheera (a child) and could also have been deemed Sabeeya (milk fed) since it was common to breast feed a child until they were infants. It was this five-year-old child that Umar chose to marry when he was in his mid fifties.

Let us now look deeper into this matter, and pose some questions for Afriki�


The marriage of fifty five year old Umar ibn al Khattab to five year old Umme Kalthum binte Abu Bakr



We read in Kanz al Ummal Volume 7 page 98:

"Umar proposed to marry Umme Kalthum binte Abu Bakr, and made the proposal to Ayesha. Ayesha replied 'She is too young, but where we will she go without you? Umme Kalthum approached Ayesha and said 'I have heard that you want to marry me to Umar. He will give me a tough life; I am in need of a young man, who loves this world. If you marry me to Umar then I shall complain before Rasulullah. Ayesha then summoned Amr bin Aas who said 'I shall deal with the matter'. Amr spoke to Umar, after a general conversation he said 'I hear that you intend on marrying'. Umar replied 'Yes'. Amr bin Aas asked 'Who?' Umar replied 'Umme Kalthum binte Abu Bakr'. Amr then said 'She is a child that shall cry for her father every day'. Umar then said 'Did Ayesha send you?'

This tradition raises some questions that we challenge Afriki and his fellow defenders of the Sahaba to answer:


  1. Umme Kalthum was under age so why did Ayesha accept Umar's invitation?
  2. If she was underage then why did the 55 year old khalifa want to marry her?
  3. When Ayesha was happy with the matter, why was Umme Kalthum complaining about the second khalifa?
  4. Abu Bakr's daughter clearly had no interest in religion, why was the Khalifa's daughter inclined in this way?
  5. We read in Sahih al Bukhari Bab ul Nikah, Volume 7, Book 62, Number 27 that Rasulullah (s) said ' you should marry the religious woman (otherwise) you will be a losers' - this being the case why did Umar want to marry an individual who clearly had no interest with the Deen?
  6. Why was the Khalifa's daughter desirous to marry a wealthy young man?
  7. Why did Umme Kalthum threaten to complain before Rasulullah (s) if she was married to Umar?

Worthy of note is the fact that she:


  • Complains of Umar's nomadic lifestyle
  • Threatens to complain before Rasulullah (s) if the marriage takes place
  • Initiates a desire to marry a rich man

Would a five-year old girl really make such comments? Are these not the comments of an adolescent / mature female? Clearly embarrassed by Umar's marriage with a five-year-old the scrupulous narrators sought to cover up her age by portraying her as older.

Let us also cite al Bidaya wa al Nihaya Volume 7 page 139:

"Umar asked Ayesha for permission to marry Umme Kalthum binte Abu Bakr, who was underage. Ayesha spoke to Umme Kalthum who said . 'No as he leads a tough lifestyle'. Ayesha then said 'You don't wish to marry Ameerul Momineen?' Umme Kalthum said 'No as his life is tough'. Ayesha then spoke with Amr bin Aas who forced Umar to withdraw his proposal".

Our questions here are as follows:


  1. When Abu Bakr's daughter was underage, what dawned on Umar to ask for her hand, by seeking the consent of her elder sister Ayesha?
  2. Ayesha was clearly aware of the young age of her sister, why did she not simply reject the offer outright?
  3. Can you really convince a five-year-old girl to get married?
  4. Would a five-year-old girl give this type of reply?

Yet again the embarrassed Ahl'ul Sunnah narrators have sought to portray Umme Kalthum binte Abu Bakr as older than she actually was, so as to cover up Umar's actions.

Let us now turn to Tareekh Kamil Volume 3 page 27 Dhikr Zawaaj Umar:

"Umar approached Ayesha with a proposal to marry Umme Kalthum. Umme Kalthum replied 'I don't want him, he leads a tough life, and is stern towards women'. Ayesha then asked for the assistance of Amr bin Aas in the matter. Amr said 'I shall deal with it'. Amr said to Umar 'I ask for Allah's forgiveness'. Umar asked 'In relation to what?' Amr said 'I have received information that you have asked for the hand of Umme Kalthum'. Umar replied 'Yes am I not deserving of this?' Amr replied 'Brother it is not that, she is a mere child brought up under the guardianship of Ameerul Momineen (Commander of the Faithful). You are a stern mannered individual, we fear you, and do not wish to clash with you, if this child opposes you, you shall become angry, then what will happen to the child? You will have failed to look after the daughter of Abu Bakr, in a manner that was incumbent on you'. Umar then said 'But I have already spoken to Ayesha'. Amr replied 'I have responsibility with regards to Ayesha'.

We would like to ask Afriki:


  1. Why did Amr bin Aas deem Umar's intention to be a serious matter from which he sought Allah (swt)'s forgiveness?
  2. Why did Umar want to marry this underage orphan girl?

Two points from the text are also worthy of note here:


  1. Who was Ameerul Momineen here? It could not have been Abu Bakr since he was not known by this title, and Ahl'ul Sunnah themselves believe Umar gave himself this title.

  2. If we accept that Ameerul Momineen here refers to Abu Bakr, then again this makes no sense since Umme Kalthum never saw her father, he died whilst she was still in her mother's womb.

Let us now analyse the matter, as recorded by Tareekh Tabari Volume 5 page 2734, Dhikr Zawaj Umar:

"Umar proposed to marry Umme Kalthum binte Abu Bakr, she was an underage child. He discussed the matter with Ayesha, she said the decision is in her hands. Umme Kalthum said 'I am not happy with regards to Umar. Ayesha said 'You don't want Ameer'ul Momineen [Commander of the Faithful]? She replied he leads a frugal existence and is tough towards women" Ayesha then sent a message to Amr bin Aas telling him. Amr replied 'Let me handle it'. He [Amr] approached Umar and said 'Commander of the faithful, I have heard some news from which I invoke God's name to protect you!". Umar asked 'What is the matter?' Amr said 'You are seeking the hand if Umme Kalthum binte 'Abu Bakr. Umar replied 'Do you not think I am worthy of her or she for me? [Amr] said, 'Neither but she was brought up with kindness and gentleness under the protection of the Mother of the Believers. You are rough and ready. But we are in awe of you and cannot turn you away from something that is natural to you. What will happen if she [Umme Kalthum] disobeys you on a matter and punish her physically? You will taken 'Abu Bakr's place as his child [protector] in a way that does not befit you'. Umar replied 'But what about Ayesha, I have already told her [that I will marry Umme Kalthum]? Amr said 'I shall deal with it on your behalf. Also I shall show someone better, Umme Kalthum binte 'Ali, through who you shall acquire a relationship with the Messenger of God"

If we are to accept this account, then it suggests that initially Umar proposed to marry Umme Kalthum binte 'Abu Bakr and then Umme Kalthum binte 'Ali (as). The alleged marriage to Umme Kalthum (as) took place in 17 Hijri, from Tabari we can deduce that Umar's proposal to Umme Kalthum binte Abu Bakr occurred in the same year, when she was just an infant of five. This reference puts to rest any Nasibi attempts to try and suggest that Umar made the proposal when she was baligh.

Again we ask some questions:


  1. Why was Umar seeking to use his influence over Ayesha so that he could marry her under age sister?
  2. Is it really believable that an underage girl would be able to decide on such a matter, particularly via such a comprehensive rebuttal?
  3. Can a woman really advise a five-year-old girl on the merits of marrying such an individual?
  4. If the daughter of Abu Bakr was under age why did the 55-year-old khalifa want to marry her?
  5. If the girl was underage why did Ayesha not point this out to Umar?
  6. Why did Umme Kalthum reject Umar the great khalifa by highlighting such defects in his character?
  7. If the concern of Amr bin Aas was that Umar's use of physical force would pain Abu Bakr, then why did he not share the same concerns with regard to the daughter of Sayyida Fatima (as)?
  8. In the eyes of Rasulullah (s) who's pain is more significant that of Abu Bakr or that of Sayyida Fatima (as)?

Let us now move on to another authentic Sunni text Tareekh Khamees Volume 2 page 239 Dhikr Zawaaj Umar:

"Umme Kalthum was the daughter of Abu Bakr, she was a young girl. Her mother was a Christian, when Abu Bakr died she was pregnant - she was hence born after Abu Bakr's death. When she grew older Umar ibn al Khattab proposed to marry her, Ayesha accepted the proposal, but Umme Kalthum binte 'Ali rejected the proposal, Ayesha therefore made some excuses and the matter was discontinued"

We would like to raise some questions:


  1. The daughter of Abu Bakr was born AFTER he died in 13 Hijri. This marriage occurred in 17 Hijri, how mature could this girl have become in a space of five years? Would she really have been physically capable of marrying 55 year old Umar?
  2. If the girl was born after her father's death, then why did Umar contemplate plans to marry this five-year-old girl?
  3. Would any responsible adult marry her five-year-old sister to a 55-year-old man?

Worthy of note is the fact that at one point the narrator makes reference to Umme Kalthum binte Abu Bakr, and yet the same text later on refers to Umme Kalthum binte 'Ali. This is clear evidence that these dishonest narrators have sought to switch names to divert attention away from Umar's desire to marry an underage girl. Tareekh Khamees is a classical Ahl'ul Sunnah text, not the hand of Ibn Saba, and here it is clearly that Nasibi hands had sought to change facts by making this tactical name change.

Let us analyse the way that Ibn Qutaybah recorded this event in al Maarif page 76, Dhikr Aulad 'Abu Bakr:

"Umar approached Ayesha with a proposal to marry Umme Kalthum binte Abu Bakr. Ayesha accepted the proposal. Umme Kalthum did not like the proposal, so Ayesha made an excuse and the matter was brought to a close".

Here we shall just raise one question:

  1. When Ayesha was fully aware of the young tender child age of her sister how did she still accept Umar's marriage proposal?

Let us now cite the final reference in this section, that from Ahl'ul Sunnah's esteemed work Riyadh al Nadira Volume 1 page 303, Dhikr Aulad Abu Bakr:

Umme Kalthum was the underage (Sagheera) daughter of Abu Bakr, she was born after Abu Bakr died. When she grew older Umar approached Ayesha with a proposal to marry her. Ayesha accepted the proposal, but Umme Kalthum did not like the idea, Ayesha made an excuse and Umar withdrew his proposal".

The reference has portrayed Abu Bakr's as underage so why did it dawn on 55 year old to marry her?


Overall summary and analysis of the texts



In summary these texts share the following common themes:


  1. 55 year old Khalifa Umar proposed to marry Umme Kalthum binte 'Abu Bakr
  2. The proposal was accepted by Ayesha
  3. Umme Kalthum rejected the proposal on account of Umar's frugal lifestyle and his attitude towards women.
  4. As a result of this opposition the marriage did not come into fruition.

When (1) & (2) are established then point (3) remains the only thing that prevented this proposal from blossoming into marriage (if we are indeed to accept these Sunni accounts) - namely the rejection of Umar by Umme Kalthum binte 'Abu Bakr. This rejection is simply not possible, is it really believable that a five year old girl would be competent enough to:


  • Understand the concept of marriage?
  • Reject the proposal, expressing her assessment of Umar, namely his lifestyle and attitude towards women?

Think rationally, can a five-year-old girl really have the intelligence to make such a coherent rejection? Clearly not, the fact is the Salaf scholars that recorded this wonderful event had sought their utmost to protect Umar's character and hence tried to make Abu Bakr's daughter sound older than her true age, and that it was this mature conscious rejection brought this matter to a close. The reality is this was simply not possible, no five-year-old girl can make such an eloquent rejection.

One of the key books of fatwa on women related issues by contemporary Salafi scholars is "Islamic Fatwa Regarding Women" compiled by Muhammed al-Musnad and translated by Jamal Zarabozo. In Chapter 9, questions related to marriage under the sub heading 'The Young Lady is not to be Forced to Marry a Man She Does Not Want to Marry', Imam of the Salafi Nasibi Shaykh bin Baz stated:

"�The father must seek her permission if she is nine years of age or above. Similarly, her other guardians may not marry her off except by her permission. This is obligatory upon all of them. If one is married without permission, then the marriage is not valid. This is because one of the conditions of the marriage is that both partners accept the marriage. If she is married without her permission, by threat or coercion, then the marriage is not valid. The only exception is in the case of the father and his daughter who is less than nine years of age. There is no harm if he gets her married while she is less than nine years old, according to the correct opinion. This is based on the Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him) marrying Ayesha without her consent when she was less than nine years old, as is stated in authentic Hadith".

This reference makes it clear that in the eyes of the Salafi, marriage with an underage girl is permissible and her consent is not required. Ayesha's sister Umm Kalthum was just five years of age when Umar made the proposal, Ayesha accepted, and according to bin Baz, her sister's consent would not be required under the Shari'a. Clearly bin Baz passed this fatwa with an awareness that a pre pubescent girl is not in the position to make a decision on such a matter. When Ayesha gave her consent, then it is not logical that she would then seek to ascertain the views of her five-year-old sister.

When Ayesha despite the young age of her sister made that decision on her behalf by accepting the proposal, then the marriage did indeed occur, since Umme Kalthum was not mature enough to decide on the matter. Once the offer and acceptance had taken place there existed no bar on this marriage occurring.

Despite the concerns of Amr bin Aas and the bride to be, the happy marriage was finally agreed. The texts of Ahl'ul Sunnah state clearly that Umar approached Ayesha directly with the marriage proposal and she agreed.
1. Tareekh Kamil Volume 3 page 41;
2. Tareekh Khamees Volume 2 page 267;
3. al Istiab Volume 2 page 795


Still embarrassed by the fact that the elderly second khalifa had the urge to marry a five year old girl, Nasibi fabricators then felt the better approach would be to swap the names of underage Umme Kalthum binte Abu Bakr with that of Umme Kalthum binte 'Ali, by doing so they had a three fold aim, they wanted to:


  1. Cover up Umar's unhealthy liking for an under age girl.
  2. Exalt the rank / status of Umar
  3. Paint a romantic image of cordial relations between Imam 'Ali (as) and Umar

Imam 'Ali (as) was not happy with the matter, but the real executors who had a say over Umme Kalthum's well being were the family of Abu Bakr. Since Hadhrath Ayesha was the head of the family, the matter was in her hands, and we read in the Hanafi madhabs esteemed book of Fiqh, Fatawa-i-'Alamgiri vol 1. Pg. 728 that when a mother does / remarries and a maternal grandmother is absent, then the sister is entitled to custody (Hizanah) of her infant child. The fact that the names were the same gave the Nasibi the opportunity to exploit the situation and present a version that did not concur with the actual facts, they changed the name binte Abu Bakr to Binte 'Ali, but through their own stupidity they failed to amend the rest of their texts. As such we were presented with narration's where the Umme Kalthum in question was so young that she was still being breast fed. Umar married only one Umme Kalthum in 17 Hijri and this was the daughter of Abu Bakr.


The aims behind marriage



Whilst Umar's desire to marry a five year old girl is despicable to any sane mind, for those die hard defenders of Umar, we would like to pose this question:

Marriage serves a number of key objectives:


  1. Every man has a natural instinct for a woman's companionship
  2. It is a means to produce offspring, and seek happiness from them
  3. Partners can reap the benefits of a comfortable life together
  4. It can have some type of worldly / materialistic benefit
  5. It can carry some religious benefit

When it is clear that not a single one of these aims would have been fulfilled by Umar's marriage to Umme Kalthum binte Abu Bakr, why did he deem it necessary marry this five year old child, particularly when he already had wives to fulfil the above aims?'

This is a question that the illegitimate descendants of Marwan and Mu'awiya will never be able to answer. They can present as many excuses as they like to explain Umar's innovations, but they will never be able to convince their own followers let alone the Shi'a that the elderly second khalifa was perfectly within his rights to consummate marriage with a five year old girl. Such a marriage was perfectly within the practices of the family of Abu Bakr which is why Ayesha had no qualms in rejecting it, for according to al Sunnah Ayesha was herself married to Rasulullah (s) at the age of six. If Ayesha could be married at the age of six, then her sister could likewise marry at the age of five. The family of Abu Bakr and Umar had always been close, in the same way that both individuals stuck closely to one another at Saqifa. Umar's marriage to Abu Bakr's daughter further cemented this friendship.


These traditions disrespect three personalities




  1. Hadhrath Ayesha - Having agreed to the proposal with Umar the Khalifa, she then breaches the agreement by making up an excuse. This type of behaviour is like those of hypocritical women, not becoming of a momin (believing) woman let alone Umm'ul Momineen.

  2. Hadhrath Umar - the comments of Umme Kalthum completely destroy Umar's character, for Umme Kalthum hated his lifestyle and rejected him on this count.

  3. Umme Kalthum - Questions can be raised as to how a materialistic minded daughter of Khalifa Abu Bakr vented such hatred for the esteemed character - Umar and openly expressed a desire to marry a young man.


Umar's motive behind marrying Umme Kalthum binte Abu Bakr



Umar's proposal for the hand of Umme Kalthum binte Abu Bakr served a number of advantages. Umme Kalthum was the younger sister of Ayesha the wife of Rasulullah (s) hence this marriage would expand Umar's rank threefold:


  1. Ayesha would become his sister in law
  2. It would have further increased his relationship to Rasulullah (s)
  3. He would become the son in law of the deceased Abu Bakr. In this connection he owed Abu Bakr two favours:



  • We learn in Sahih al Bukhari Bab ul Nikah that Rasulullah (s) married Hafsa after Abu Bakr turned down the initial offer.
  • Ignoring the concept of Shura / elections and the protestations of the Sahaba, Abu Bakr appointed Umar as his Khalifa.

An 'in law' relationship and station as Khalifa were positions that were attained thanks to Abu Bakr. Umar was forever indebted to Ibn Abu Quhafa and hence he wanted to repay this debt by marrying his daughter and exalting her to the status of the 'The first lady' over the Muslims.

Now that we have been able to determine the true identity of Umme Kalthum wife of Umar, we go into Chapter Five making use of this new found knowledge and hence a better understanding of the Shi'a traditions�